Meet Our Staff

Our staff here at Craig Toyota is here for your convenience. Feel free to contact us with questions or for a test drive.

Meet Our New & Used Staff

Slaes & Leasing Consultant Mark  McKee
X
Mark comes to us from 16 years with the Madison Courier. He will be visiting a lot of his previous customers to offer assistance in their future automotive needs.
Slaes & Leasing Consultant
Mark McKee
Sales & Leasing Consultant Tracy Morrison
X
Tracy brings many years of automotive sales experience from the North Vernon area. He looks forward to seeing his previous customers as well as making new ones.
Sales & Leasing Consultant
Tracy Morrison

Meet Our Sales Staff

Dealer Principal Joe  Craig
X
888-273-3135
Dealer Principal
Joe Craig
Used Car Manager and New Business Development Andy  Craig
X
888-273-3135
Used Car Manager and New Busin
Andy Craig
Sales Manager Greg  Sanders
X
Greg was born and raised in the Madison area. He is a graduate of Southwestern High School and supports Rebel athletics. Greg is married with three children. His oldest son Jake, resides in Austin, TX. His daughter Sarah, lives in Lexington, KY and his youngest, Ty attends Southwestern and is on their archery team. Greg began his automotive career in 1996 and brings his years of experience to the Craig team to assist all the great customers with their next vehicle purchase.
Sales Manager
Greg Sanders
Sales Assistant Mark  Andrew
X
Mark and his wife Cindy have 3 college graduate children and reside in Madison. Mark enjoys golf and coaching basketball in his off time. Mark can be reached at 888-273-3135 or [email protected]
Sales Assistant
Mark Andrew
Sales and Leasing Consultant Bill  Sullivan
X
Bill started selling cars in August of 1968 and brings many years of sales experience to the sales floor. Bill started with Craig Toyota in March of 2007 and continues to service his extensive well satisfied customer base while continuing to build new relationships along the way. Bill Enjoys traveling and desserts, especially those made by his customers! Bill can be reached at 888-273-3135 or bill [email protected]
Sales and Leasing Consultant
Bill Sullivan
Sales & Leasing Consultant Tim  Williams
X
Tim comes to us from Eastern Kentucky and brings 20 years of experience to Craig Toyota where he has been for the last 15 years. Tim lives with his wife Emma in Hanover and has 3 grand children and 2 dogs. Tim enjoys metal detecting and University of Kentucky Sports. Tim can be reached at 888-273-3135 or [email protected]
Sales & Leasing Consultant
Tim Williams
Sales & Leasing Consultant Tim  Jones
X
Tim started with us for the second time in 2004 and has been in the car business since 1993. Tim resides in Madison. He enjoys sports, gardening and cooking. Tim can be reached by phone at 888-273-3135 or [email protected]
Sales & Leasing Consultant
Tim Jones
Sales & Leasing Consultant Michael  Perry
X
Sales & Leasing Consultant
Michael Perry
Slaes & Leasing Consultant Mark  McKee
X
Mark comes to us from 16 years with the Madison Courier. He will be visiting a lot of his previous customers to offer assistance in their future automotive needs.
Slaes & Leasing Consultant
Mark McKee
Sales & Leasing Consultant Tracy Morrison
X
Tracy brings many years of automotive sales experience from the North Vernon area. He looks forward to seeing his previous customers as well as making new ones.
Sales & Leasing Consultant
Tracy Morrison

Meet Our Service Staff

Service Manager Jason  Tague
X
Service Manager
Jason Tague
Assistant Service Manager Jerry  Tingle
X
Assistant Service Manager
Jerry Tingle
Generic Staff Photo
X
Service Writer
Joe Vest
Generic Staff Photo
X
Service Writer
Sarah Kernen

Meet Our Parts Staff

Secretary / Treasurer / Parts Manager John  Craig
X
888-273-3135
Secretary / Treasurer / Parts
John Craig
Generic Staff Photo
X
812-273-3135
Parts associate
Jim Colen
Generic Staff Photo
X
Parts consultant
Rick Burress

Meet Our Body Shop Staff

Generic Staff Photo
X
David has worked in the body shop for quite a while and does great work along with Tony Peelman and Ernie Keith. David has taken over the role of Body Shop Manager.
Body Shop Scheduling and Follo
David Burnham
Generic Staff Photo
X
Body Technician
Tony Peelman
Generic Staff Photo
X
Body Technician
Ernie Keith

Meet Our Internet Staff

E-Commerce Director Dave  Tingle Sr
X
Dave has been in the car business for over 30 years and has been with Craig Toyota's sales department since 2001. He has held various positions over the years and is the current E-Commerce Director while backing up the sales manager and handling inventory management. Dave is single and lives in Madison and enjoys westerns, travel and NASCAR and Pro football. Dave can be reached at 888-273-3135 or [email protected]
E-Commerce Director
Dave Tingle Sr

Meet Our Finance Staff

Business and F&I Manager Hanna Doty
X
Hanna joined our team in June of 2017. She came to us from another store that was run by her family here in Madison. Hanna is our Business and F&I manager. She is local to Madison and loves her hometown. In her free time she enjoys traveling and spending time with her family. Hanna can be reached at 812-273-3135 or by email at [email protected]
Business and F&I Manager
Hanna Doty

Our Location

Craig Toyota
258 Clifty Drive
Madison, IN 47250

Sales: (888) 273-3135
Scroll Up

Sales Hours

Internet Hours

Service Hours

Parts Hours

Finance Hours

Body Shop Hours

New & Used Hours

Scroll Down

Normally when I write a letter like this, I am complaining about something, but this is not the case here. On January of this year, I had scheduled an appointment with Craig's to have the headlight shields on our Camry polished (light output was dim). Since we live near Greensburg, we are fifty...

- John Vanderbur, Greensburg

The car is great, and as I said before, I plan on driving it until the wheels fall off. There is something I don't like about it (not your fault), the rear end is light and if it is windy it seems to sway. It makes me feel insecure in the freeways, but I am a careful driver and I think it will be...

- Lianna McKinney, North Vernon, In.

Linda Morrow's Overall Rating 5.0 Buying Process: 5.0 Overall Facilities: 5.0 We were referred by friends to come to Craig Toyota looking for a new RAV4 and we were truly glad we did! We were greeted by Brittany and we told her what we were looking for. She showed us a new RAV4...

- Linda Morrow, Seymour, In.

Excellent Service!!! Teresa Whittington's Overall Rating 5.0 Customer Service: 5.0 Buying Process: 5.0 Quality of Repair: 0.0 Overall Facilities: 5.0 by Teresa Whittington from Hope, Indiana | November 12, 2019 I would recommend any one of my friends and family to come here...

- Teresa Whittington, Hope, In 47250

Very Good Experience!!!! Josh and Tasha Rose's Overall Rating 5.0 Customer Service: 5.0 Buying Process: 5.0 Quality of Repair: 0.0 Overall Facilities: 5.0 by Josh and Tasha Rose from Vevay, Indiana | April 25, 2015 Process was easy and they were very good to deal with. Stacy...

- Josh & Tasha Rose, Vevay, In 47043

GREAT SALES!!!!!!! Marissa Hatton and David Dayadharum's Overall Rating 5.0 Customer Service: 5.0 Buying Process: 5.0 Quality of Repair: 0.0 Overall Facilities: 5.0 by Marissa Hatton and David Dayadharum from Warsaw, Kentucky | November 21. 2019 They were very helpful with...

- Marissa Hatton & David Dayadharum, Warsaw, Ky.

Would highly recommend!!! Corrina Melvin's Overall Rating 5.0 Customer Service: 5.0 Buying Process: 5.0 Quality of Repair: 0.0 Overall Facilities: 5.0 by Corrina Melvin from Bedford, KY | November 7, 2019 Went car shopping with my 18 year old daughter. This was to be her...

- Corrina Melvin, Bedford Ky.

by Brian Otter from Florence, IN | October 30 2019 Had a great experience. Not too much hassle in buying. Bill Sullivan did a great job contacting me. When I came in to buy Bill was on vacation and the sales team Stacy Demaree, Tim Williams, and Mark Andrew did a great job helping me and...

- Brian Otter, Florence, In.

Awesome!!! By SP Romans from Madison, Indiana | October 17, 2019 We have purchased many vehicles in the past and have never received the quality of service that we received at Craig Toyota. Mike, the Business Manager, handled our paperwork. He was extremely polite and explained every part of the...

- SP Romans, Madison, In

I didn't really plan on buying a car, I was actually beginning to look for a car for my daughter for work this summer. I only buy a car every 10-12 years because I hate the buying process with the typical process and typical high pressure salesmen. Guess I had never been to Craig Toyota before....

- Anne Cusker, Madiosn,In

Dear Dave, I want to thank you for the outstanding help you gave me while shopping for my new Tacoma Pick up truck! I love that truck but I also feel I have made a new friend. I look forward to future shopping with you! Diane Taylor

- Diane Taylor, Ghent Ky

I would like to take this opportunity to express our gratitude for the recent new car purchase at your company. We found our salesman, Tim Jones, to be very knowledgeable and affable making the purchase of our new automobile a pleasant experience. So often today, buyers are confronted by high...

- Fred Black, Dupont, In
View All Testimonials